Lake District or Peak District: which UK national park to explore

Besides Stonehenge, England hosts some of the most iconic geological wonders for anyone seeking refuge from their hectic schedule.

The English country has it all, from hauntingly beautiful landscapes straight out of Emily Bronte’s novels to exhilarating peaks that’ll get your blood pumping.

Come adventure season, however, nothing quite draws the fancy of explorers besides the Lake District and the Peak District.

Choosing between these two exceptional sightseeing spots is a real dilemma, mind. Both are impossibly beautiful and offer a myriad of activities and sights.

So, I understand if you’re stuck choosing between the Lake District or Peak District for your holiday getaway destination. But let me get you out of that exasperating limbo of indecision, shall we? 

In this post, I’ll share essential insights to help you decide between the two outstanding England travel spots.

Whether you’re drawn to breathtaking vistas of undulating Cumbrian ridges of the lakes or the picturesque medieval villages of the peaks, let’s explore what makes these districts worthy of your attention.

This post contains affiliate links.

A brief overview of the Lake District and Peak District

It’s absolutely possible to reach both national parks via public transport. However, if you’re able to drive then I really do recommend this as an option.

It’ll give you the most flexibility in terms of exploring when you’re actually in each destination. As some spots are a bit off the beaten track, they’re not always reachable by public transport.

Peak District: where wilderness meets history

Peak District lies at the heart of England in Derbyshire, an enchanting novel-like setting teeming with wide-open heaths, twisty forests, and fascinating legends.

The dramatic geology makes for the perfect location if you enjoy horse riding, rock climbing, cycling, hiking, or anything that gets the thrill going.

Just imagine thousands of kilometres of crisscrossing footpaths, all waiting for you to explore.

Or think of deep wooded dales, whitewashed limestone gorges, and cragged elevations, luring anyone with adventurous hearts in.

As England’s first and oldest national park, the Peak District certainly exudes an air of irresistible majesty.

To take the effort out of planning, book a day trip to the Peak District from Manchester.

Lake District: where human and nature’s splendour collide

Nestled in the county of Cumbria, the Lake District is a scenic destination no less stunning than the Peak District.

With its awe-inspiring scapes, the Lake District has attracted countless distinguished literary figures, from William Wordsworth and Alfred Wainwright to John Ruskin.

I can’t blame them, though. Hidden in Cumbria lies endless sylvan plains, spectacular hills, dazzling meadows, deep water stretches, and jaw-dropping peaks.

Yet, the lakes offer more than just a scenic tour.

As in the words of Daniel Defoe, the Cumbrian gem is “high and formidable” with “a kind of inhospitable terror in them.” For adrenaline junkies like myself, that only translates to adventures galore!

There are infinite ways to enjoy Lake District’s scapes to get your heart racing, from rafting, canyoning, sailing, and caving, to family-friendly hiking, swimming, and boat cruising.

Getting to the Lake District and Peak District

Both districts are well-connected, so getting to and around them is relatively easy even if you’re coming in from further afield or outside Europe.

There’s no shortage of transportation options to choose from after landing, whether you prefer trains, coaches, or buses.

Getting to the Peak District

The most convenient airports to fly into to get to the Peak District are Manchester and East Midlands Airport. 

Flying into Birmingham, London or another UK airport is also possible depending on where you’re coming from.

Local rail networks connect the Peak District with Manchester, Derby, and Sheffield. You can travel to these cities no matter where you are in the country via mainline trains.

Once you reach Manchester, Derby, or Sheffield, the Peak District will be one train hop away. 

I find trains to be better than buses because they often stop at famous towns, villages, and landmarks, making exploring easier.

Coaches are a great way to get around, too. National Express and Megabus operate in Derby, Manchester, Sheffield, and other major cities and towns.

Getting to the Lake District

The airports in Glasgow and Manchester are the closest landing spots to the Lake District, separated only by a short bus or coach ride.

Anyone planning a quick detour outside the Lake District may also fly into Carlisle Lake District Airport from Belfast, Southend London, and Dublin.

For those bringing their vehicles for the freedom of exploring without a strict schedule, the M6 motorway connecting the Midland to the Scottish border is your ideal path.

Driving takes 2 to 5 hours depending on which city you start from.

For an easy option without the hassle, book a full-day tour of the Lake District.

Things to do in the Lake District and Peak District

While both regions boast exhilarating promenades of landscapes and thrilling activities, there’s a slight difference between the things you can see and do.

I’d say that the Peak District suits those who prefer a more laid-back exploration of literary culture, medieval architecture, and wondrous natural settings – with a touch of heart-pumping adventure on the sidelines.

The Lake District, on the other hand, is the perfect playground for hikers and adrenaline chasers. 

Top things to do in the Peak District

Immerse in literary history: If you’re a fan of Pride and Prejudice, visiting the Peak District lets you peek at Chatsworth House.

It was the famous home of Mr Darcy in the 2005 film adaptation of the novel. With luck, you may even participate in the annual Regency Ball and Country Fair.

Become entranced in local folklore and myths: The Peak District has an abundance of eerie legends. My favourite is the famous Lud’s Church, which is said to be the devil’s handiwork, as well as the Winking Man rock formation.

Witness the Roaches’ breathtaking views: It’s not the most appealing name. But witnessing the harsh gritstone ridge soaring above the historic Queen of the Staffordshire Moorlands is not to be missed.

Relish the view of picture-perfect medieval towns: Exploring the Peak District is endlessly exciting. I love driving around here, relishing picturesque views of medieval towns and enchanting ruins.

Top things to do in the Lake District

Experience England’s best walking trails: The Lake District has some of the best walking trails in England, offering different distance and difficulty levels for everyone.

But if I had to choose a favourite, I’d pick the hike to the Castlerigg Stone Circle, which only takes roughly 30 minutes.

Scale England’s highest point: The Scafell Pike, reaching 978m above sea level, is the highest peak in all of England. Perfect if you’re looking for a challenge!

Relive Beatrix Potter’s life from her home: Visit the charming and leafy home of world-renowned author Beatrix Potter. Roam her famous garden and view life from the eyes of the literary giant.

Witness Keswick’s spellbinding locations: Surrounded by cloud-curtained fells, Keswick is a spectacular town hidden in the most northern parts of the Lake District.

Coddled beside the dreamlike lake of Derwentwater, sailing around is the best way to go.

Discover more of the best things to do in the Lake District or unearth my favourite hidden gems in the Lake District.

Food and drink scene: Lake District or Peak District?

Both the Peak District and Lake District are huge for cafes and pubs. They’re also peppered with superb farmers’ markets and shops, boasting local produce from passionate growers.

I’m a fan of Peak District’s Bakewell Pudding, England’s quintessential dessert baked in the famed town of Bakewell.

But for anyone looking for the freshest pint, most would agree that Lake District’s Drunken Duck is unrivalled. And let’s not forget Grasmere Gingerbread!

For me, the Lake District wins the foodie crown. There are an impressive number of Michelin restaurants in the Lake District, plus a myriad of delightful afternoon tea spots.

Lake or Peak District: other considerations

History and culture

Both the Lake District and Peak District provide hordes of treasured artefacts. Whether you prefer one over the other largely depends on your preferences.

The Peak District has Chatsworth House, which dates back to the 16th century and is a well-preserved museum of invaluable art collections.

Inside, you can find works from famous painters like Rembrandt, Lucien Freud, and Sargent.

The Lake District is no less impressive. You’ll find Dove Cottage, William Wordsworth’s home of eight years, and the Wordsworth Museum, featuring the celebrated poet’s handwritten letters, journals, and manuscripts.

Wildlife

The Peak District is home to a diverse range of wildlife. If you keep a close eye out while exploring, you may happen upon some red deer, badgers, and hares.

Birdwatchers, particularly, will have a field day on the moorlands of the national park.

Patrolling the peak’s blue skies are kestrels, hen harriers, dunlin, starlings, and the rare bearded vultures.

Still, that’s not to say Lake District is anywhere less populous. In Derwentwater alone, waders, waterfowl, snipes, and sandpipers flock in abundance. 

Accommodation options

Accommodation is where the lakes have a slight edge over the peaks. That isn’t to say that there aren’t some fabulous options in the Peak District though.

In the park’s southern end lies Callow Hall, previously named hotel of the year by The Times.

Or you can drive over to the humble village of Little Hucklow, and find the local-favourite pub, the Blind Bull.

On the other hand, the Lake District offers an abundance of incredible hotels.

Some of my favourites include Gilpin Hotel & Lake House, Storrs Hall and Brimstone.

When to visit

I’d recommend visiting either of these tourist hotspots from May to September if you’re chasing the best weather for the best views.

For those looking to cut costs, October onwards will have the best price deals for hotels and dining. Plus, you’ll have the gorgeous hues of autumnal colours.

Final thoughts

The Peak District is a superb choice for those looking for a relaxing escape, with plenty of historical heritage and unthreaded moors to explore. 

Yet, there’s a reason Lake District is England’s favourite national park.

If you’re looking for a better thrill factor alongside scenic untamed paths, then book your ticket to the Lake District. 

Do you have a favourite between the Lake District vs Peak District? Let me know in the comments below!

If you’re planning a trip to the Lake District, check out my guides below:

• 23 amazing things to do in the Lake District
• 20 pretty Lake District villages and towns to visit
• 10 breathtaking hidden gems in the Lake District